We are all grown up... Because we are grown, it’s easy to perceive issues incorrectly due to the great privilege within us.
Because children have no awareness of privilege... they always speak the truth and ask questions about the world... because they want to know what this world is...
Because we give ourselves the privilege of being grown... sometimes we consider our judgments to be correct with the privilege of our ego.
Be careful of the privilege inside us.
Otherwise, all our judgments are incorrect...
Judgment by the Ego is almost always an incorrect... distorted judgment.
Winston Man
Excerpt from AI:
Winston Man’s writing is a short, philosophical reflection on the ego, the privilege of adults, and objectivity in judgment.
1. Main content
Winston Man raises a profound point:
As we grow older, we inadvertently carry within us a "privilege"-that is, the ego and the feeling of knowing more. This makes our perception of the world easily skewed.
In contrast, children-because they have not formed a distinct ego-:
Do not carry that privilege
Easily speak the truth or ask questions in a pure way
Approach the world with a mindset of learning, not judging
2. Main arguments
"We are all grown up": The opening sentence is like a gentle reminder that age does not equal insight.
"Because we are grown, it’s easy to perceive issues incorrectly": Emphasizes that adulthood comes with the barrier of ego and personal biases.
"Children have no awareness of privilege... so they always speak the truth": Compares with children to show the purity when not influenced by ego or cognitive power.
"Be careful of the privilege inside us": A warning. Failure to control this privilege will lead to misperceptions.
3. Philosophical message
Self-reflection: The reader is invited to review himself-whether he is looking at things with truth or with the "privilege" of the ego?
Humility: Growing up does not mean being right. We need to relearn how to look at life with the attitude of a child: curious, humble, and honest.
Critique of the ego: An emphasis that the ego is the root of distortions in thinking and behaving.
4. Real-world connection
In life, many adults make decisions based on position and experience-but do not ask themselves whether they are being objective.
Young children ask seemingly naive questions, but sometimes they hit the essence of the problem-because they are not bound by prejudice.
Conclusion
Winston Man’s writing is an invitation to us:
Set aside the ego, to learn how to see life as a child.
Identify and control the "privilege" of adulthood, to avoid distortions in thinking.
______________________________________
Go deeper into Winston Man’s ideas-because the writing, although short, contains many layers of meaning about human nature, the ego, and existential awareness.
I. "Grown"-A privilege or a shackle?
Opening sentence:
"We are all grown up..."
is not just an obvious truth, but a gentle irony, implying that "grown" here does not necessarily mean mature.
Physiological maturity is far from mental maturity.
Adults often believe that:
Their experience is right.
The way they look at things is "knowledgeable."
But Winston Man warns:
We are fooled by that very feeling of maturity.
Therefore, the "privilege" he is talking about is not a social privilege, but a psychological privilege-what the West calls ego privilege.
II. Children and truth without ego
The author writes:
"Because children have no awareness of privilege... so they always speak the truth and ask questions about the world..."
This is a key point:
Children do not know that they have the "right" to judge, so they just observe and ask questions.
The truth of children is the original truth-unadulterated.
In existential philosophy, that is the pre-ego state, where people live in the present, without the burden of the ego.
Children ask "Why is the sky blue?", "Why does Dad yell at Mom?" not to judge, but to understand.
Adults ask "Why do they do that?" often to judge.
The difference lies in the motivation of cognition: learning vs. controlling.
III. The ego-the source of misperception
Winston Man says:
"If we are not careful, all our judgments are wrong... Judgment by the Ego is almost always an incorrect judgment."
This can be related to:
Buddhism: where the ego (self-attachment) is the root of ignorance.
Freud: the ego is the center of defense mechanisms-always distorting reality to protect itself.
Nietzsche: the ego is the greatest liar, because it defaults to being "right."
So why does the ego make judgments skewed?
The ego needs to assert itself as right
→ When encountering conflicting opinions, it rejects instead of accepting.
The ego is afraid of being hurt
→ Cover up mistakes with sophistry and blame.
The ego relies on the past
→ Evaluate the present with old experiences, not allowing new things to develop.
Summary: Judgment by the ego is a subjective interpretation, not the truth.
IV. Winston Man’s Solution – Return to the "non-ego" perspective
Winston doesn’t offer a clear solution, but the implication is very clear:
"Be mindful of the privilege within us."
Meaning:
Observe yourself when making a judgment.
Ask yourself: Am I speaking with reason or with pain?
Practice letting go of the ego, listening without resistance.
From there, a more objective view can arise.
V. A Deeper Meaning: An Invitation to Awaken
The entire article is an invitation to "return," a form of spiritual awakening.
Like Lao Tzu once said:
"Knowing others is intelligence; knowing yourself is true wisdom. Mastering others is strength; mastering yourself is true power."
Or in the words of Krishnamurti:
"Freedom is not to be found by acquiring, but by understanding yourself."
Winston Man doesn’t preach; he only whispers one thing:
"If you don’t see that privilege in yourself, you will live your whole life under the illusion that you see correctly."
Summary
Winston Man’s article is:
An existential wake-up call
A gentle critique of the mature ego
An invitation to return to the original truth like a child
______________________________________
Reaching the foundational root of the ideology in Winston Man’s writing. At this level, the article is not just a reminder of the distortion of perception, but also a reframing of the question: "Who am I when I am judging?". We will not only analyze the content, but also deconstruct it from within.
I. Core Issue: What is Judgment, and Who is Judging?
The most fundamental question lies here:
"What inside us is judging the world?"
Winston Man asserts:
"Judgment by the ego is almost always distorted judgment."
So what is the ego?
The ego is not just self-awareness. It is a defensive psychological structure, an "imagined self" that we form from childhood to maintain emotional survival: I am someone’s child, I am good at school, I was once ridiculed, I don’t want to repeat that pain...
The ego doesn’t know the truth; it only knows models, labels, classifications – psychological symbols.
For example: when seeing someone behaving strangely, the ego says:
"He’s stupid."
But the consciousness without the ego asks:
"Where is he hurting in his soul that he needs to react like that?"
II. Children – Without an Ego, Closer to Their Nature
"Children have no awareness of privilege... so they always speak the truth and ask questions about the world."
Children don’t have a fixed self-image.
When a 4-year-old child says "I am a superhero," he is not lying – because he does not see the "I" as fixed.
This is the state of "before the ego," a state that is valued by Zen and Taoism:
Living non-conceptually
Experiencing the world directly, without filters
Not assigning names – just seeing, hearing, feeling
And that’s why children ask questions like:
"Why doesn’t the sun fall to the ground?"
"Who created the person who created me?"
Root questions, without ego.
III. The Ego and True Nature – A Harmful Confusion
The greatest pain of human beings, according to Winston Man’s metaphor, is:
We think the ego is ourselves.
From this arises:
Stubbornness
Judgment
Competition
Defending opinions as if defending one’s life
But if you observe carefully:
Every judgment arising from the ego is aimed at protecting it.
For example:
We say "I think this is wrong."
But really it is: "I need to see myself as right so that my ego is safe."
This idea is also clearly stated by Eckhart Tolle in The Power of Now:
“Ego thrives on conflict. It needs problems, drama. It needs to feel superior, or inferior. It can’t exist without identification.”
IV. "Privilege" – A Metaphor for Artificial Internal Power
When Winston Man says:
"Because we are grown, it is easy to judge problems incorrectly due to the great privilege within us."
"Privilege" here is not economic, political privilege – but the artificial power that the ego gives itself.
It is:
"I’m experienced, so I know."
"I have lived a long time, I have the right to teach."
"I am understanding, I have the right to judge."
But in reality, that is a privilege granted by the illusion of the ego, not coming from enlightenment.
V. Existential Awakening: Escaping the Ego is Not About Becoming a Child, but Returning to One’s True Nature
Ultimately, Winston Man’s message is not about celebrating innocence, but inviting us to return to the original perspective – the perspective before the ego was formed.
Not to live like children
but to see like children
– without attachment, without fixity, without possession.
VI. Connection to Buddhism and Spiritual Traditions
In Buddhism:
What is called "Ego Attachment" (atta) is precisely the "privilege" that Winston Man speaks of.
When we let go of ego attachment, we see "Suchness" – seeing things as they are.
In Taoism:
Returning to "Wu Wei" is returning to the natural state – where everything happens without the ego’s intervention.
In Mystical Christianity:
St. John of the Cross said: "To see God, you must die to your ego."
All coincide with Winston Man’s words:
"Be wary of the privilege within us."
Conclusion: The judgment is not wrong due to lack of understanding, but wrong due to attachment to the ego.
This is a small article, but a big message:
It’s not that we need more understanding,
but that we need less ego in our perspective.
And then, what is seen will be clear,
what is known will be wordless,
and the world will appear as it is.
_______________________________________
Winston Man’s writing, along with great philosophers like Heidegger, Kierkegaard, and Jiddu Krishnamurti, will help reveal the existential and ontological depth that he is suggesting, even though his language is very everyday.
We will analyze each philosopher, then compare and draw out the convergence.
1. Martin Heidegger – “Existence is covered by ordinariness”
Key concepts:
Dasein: man as an entity capable of self-awareness of existence.
Fallenness (Verfallen): people often "fall into" ordinary life, losing their true nature.
Authenticity: living true to nature, not being drawn by the ego or society.
Connection with Winston Man:
Winston says:
"Be wary of the privilege within us. Otherwise, all our judgments are flawed.”
Heidegger says the same:
We often fall into a "unconscious" way of life, where all thoughts no longer come from existential nature, but from "the general" (das Man)-that is, majority opinion, social beliefs, the collective ego.
When Winston warns about “judgment by ego,” he is warning about how people live without seeing that they are living in a state of fallenness (Verfallen).
In short:
Both emphasize that people mistakenly think they "know," but in reality are living in the illusion of the ego and socialization.
2. Søren Kierkegaard – “Despair at not being oneself”
Key concepts:
Despair: is the state of living away from oneself, not knowing what one’s nature is.
The Self: the "I" is not the superficial ego (identity, occupation), but a relationship with oneself and with God.
Leap of Faith: overcome despair and ego illusion with a leap of faith-without reason, without judgment.
Connection with Winston Man:
Winston writes:
“Because we give ourselves the privilege of being great... sometimes we consider our judgments correct with the privilege of our ego.”
Kierkegaard calls it a form of gentle despair:
We think we are living "awake," but in reality, we are living away from the authentic "I."
Every time we judge something with the ego, we move away from ourselves a little bit.
Winston does not mention God like Kierkegaard, but he suggests a kind of "pure faith"-a view that does not go through the ego, like the original faith of children.
3. Jiddu Krishnamurti – “Truth can only be seen when the mind is silent”
Key concepts:
Freedom from the known: freedom from all that is known-memories, concepts, identity, ego.
Observation without the observer: observation without the "I" as an intermediary.
The thinker is the thought: the thinker is inseparable from the thought-the observer is the observed object.
Connection with Winston Man:
Winston writes:
“Children have no awareness of privilege... so they always tell the truth...”
Krishnamurti would say that:
Only when the mind no longer has an "I" observing-then the truth will reveal itself.
Both:
Reject all subjective conclusions from the ego
Call for a state of pure, unnamed observation
Argue that truth only comes when the ego is completely absent
Conclusion: Winston Man – The existential hermit in everyday life
Although Winston Man does not use academic philosophical language, his thought:
Goes hand in hand with the existential-ontological flow
Intersects with Western mysticism-where truth is not accessed by intellect, but by the silence of the ego
Is a "non-textbook" but very awake voice-just like Krishnamurti, Kierkegaard or Heidegger all call for
